Category:Peerproduction
This will function as a mini-guide to Peer Production proper, in the more narrow sense, so that this key material is no longer only available through our almost unwieldy section on P2P Business trends in general.
We recommend the following 2 articles outlining the role of the P2P Foundation, 'which peer produces knowledge about peer production'.
- Prophets and Advocates of Peer Production. By George Dafermos. [1]. Excellent introduction to the role of the P2P Foundation in the context of the re-emergence of a commons movement that is linked to digitally-enabled self-organization.
- Digital Commons: Cyber-Commoners, Peer Producers and the Project of a Post-Capitalist Transition. By George Dafermos. [2]: Excellent introduction to the theoretical and strategic work of the P2P Foundation.
Introduction
- The Common as a Mode of Production. Towards a critique of the political economy of common goods. Carlo Vercellone. [3]
- Christian Siefkes: Peer Producing Plenty in the Physical World
- Karim Lakhani on the Open Source Software communities Open Development process [4]
- A Bibliography on Peer Production. Recommendations by James Boyle.
- Georgie BC: How a Stigmergy of Actions Replaces Representation of Persons
- Dmytri Kleiner: Flawed Circuits of Value in the Lulz Economy
More on a potential future form:
- Commons-Oriented Decentralised Programmed Organisations, i.e. cDPOs "are frameworks to bootstrap, develop & sustain commons projects"., aka, the commons-oriented version of DAO's. More info in the article: Programmed Decentralised Commons Production. [5]
Characteristics of Peer Production
- Peer Production Patterns, summarized by Stefan Meretz:
- Beyond Classes
- Beyond Commodity
- Beyond Exchange
- Beyond Exclusion
- Beyond Labor
- Beyond Money
- Beyond Politics
- Beyond Scarcity
- Beyond Socialism
- Peer production carries with it many different fundamental innovations, that are starkly different from traditional business practice. Here are a number of these practices, contrasted with the practices
of the market and the business firm:
- Anti-Credentialism: refers to the inclusiveness of peer production. What matters is the ability to carry out a particular task, not any formal a priori credential ( ≠ credentialism).
- Anti-Rivalry: sharing the created goods does not diminish the value of the good, but actually enhances it ( ≠ rivalry).
- Communal Validation: the quality control is not a 'a priori' condition of participation, but a post-hoc control process, usually community-driven ( ≠ hierarchical control).
- Distribution of Tasks: there are no roles and jobs to be performed, only specific tasks to be carried out ( ≠ division of labor).
- Equipotentiality: people are judged on the particular aspects of their being that is involved in the execution of a particular task ( ≠ people ranking).
- For Benefit: (Benefit Sharing; Benefit-Driven Production). The production aims to create use value or 'benefits' for its user community, not profits for shareholders ( ≠ for-profit).
- Forking: the freedom to copy and modify includes the possibility to take the project into a different direction ( ≠ one authorized version).
- Granularity: refers to the effort to create the smallest possible modules (see Modularity infra), so that the treshold of participation for carrying out tasks is lowered to the lowest possible extent.
- Holoptism; transparency is the default state of information about the project; all additions can be seen and verified and are sourced ( ≠ panoptism).
- Modularity: tasks, products and services are organized as modules, that fit with other modules in a puzzle that is continuously re-assembled; anybody can contribute to any module. (See also: Composability, from software engineering terminology, [http//:wikipedia.org/wiki/Composability])
- Negotiated Coordination: conflicts are resolved through an ongoing and mediated dialogue, not by fiat and top-down decisions ( ≠ centralized and hierarchical decision-making). (See also "subsidiarity", "the delegation of decision-making power over a particular area of operation by those working directly in that area." [6])
- Permissionlessness: one does not need permission to contribute to the commons( ≠ permission culture).
- Produsage: there is no strict separation between production and consumption, and users can produce solutions ( ≠ production for consumption).
- Stigmergy: there is a signalling language that permits system needs to be broadcast and matched to contributions.
Suggested characteristics: (composability, Subsidiarity)
Quotes
“Since evolutionary changes are not completely predictable, it is obvious that there is room in the world for what we call free will. Each individual decision to accept, resist, or change the current order alters the probability that a particular evolution outcome will occur. While the course of cultural evolution is never free from systemic influence, some moments are probably more “open” than others. The most open moments, it appears to me, are those at which a mode of production reaches its limits of growth and a new mode of production must soon be adopted. We are rapidly moving toward such an opening.”
- Marvin Harris - “Cannibals and Kings” P.291
With the advent of the P2P Mode of Production, the community and its common is now the appropriate scale
"We’re seeing something that is historically shocking—the reduction to zero of the cost of an especially valuable part of capital, which materializes directly knowledge (free software, free designs, etc.). And above all we see, almost day by day, how the optimum size of production, sector by sector, approaches or reaches the community dimension.
The possibility for the real community, the one based on interpersonal relationships and affections, to be an efficient productive unit is something radically new, and its potential to empower is far from having been developed. This means that we are lucky enough to live in a historical moment when it would seem that the whole history of technology, with all its social and political challenges, has coalesced to put us within reach of the possibility of developing ourselves in a new way and contributing autonomy to our community.
Today we have an opportunity that previous generations did not: to transform production into something done, and enjoyed, among peers. We can make work a time that is not walled off from life itself, which capitalism revealingly calls “time off.” That’s the ultimate meaning of producing in common today. That’s the immediate course of every emancipatory action. The starting point."
- David de Ugarte [7]
On the connection between Modularity and Sharing
"If the stuff to hand isn't modular, you can't really share, because your stuff isn't compatible with other people's stuff. If it isn't modular, you can't share out tasks and scale. If you can't share out tasks, you can't have people working independently, at their own pace and in their own way, which means the project isn't really open. If it isn't modular, you can't swap in some new elements while leaving everything else untouched, which means no "release early, release often", no experimentation, no rapid evolution. Modularity is indispensable."
- Glyn Moody: [8]
The Best Anthropological Definition of Equality Points To Peer Production
"The best anthropological definition of egalitarian societies, that proposed by Fried (1967): in egalitarian societies there are as many positions as there are qualified individuals to fill them. The respect for the abilities of different individuals creates tolerance for the variation on which cultural developments draw. Egalitarian and hierarchical elements co-exist in all human societies. Though both appear to have roots in our simian heritage, why were both maintained through social selection and cultural means? Institutionalized hierarchy reduces internal competition and the often-destructive race to the top, allows for efficient organization of collective action, and coordinates responses to intergroup competition which benefit many group members. Egalitarian institutions reduce the transaction costs of social and economic exchange in a number of respects. As equals, it is not necessary to work out relative social standing with every interaction. Women and men can help each other knowing that as equals they can give, ask, take and receive help when in need. With egalitarian institutions people do not fear that assistance given will be used to dominate, fostering the conditions and trust for delayed exchange. Finally, equality facilitates the mobility necessary for intergroup interaction, as hierarchies do not mesh easily."
- Polly Wiessner [9]
Key Resources
Key Articles
- Foundational Essay: "The Political Economy of Peer Production", Michel Bauwens's 2005 essay published in Ctheory
- Update from 2009: Class and Capital in Peer Production. Michel Bauwens. Capital & Class Spring 2009 vol. 33 no. 1 121-141 [10]
- Overview Essay: Prophets and Advocates of Peer Production. By George Dafermos. Chapter 7: The Handbook of Peer Production. Wiley, 2020
Important Details via:
- Paul Hartzog on the Advantages of Scale of Openness and Peer Production
- Dmytri Kleiner's Critique of Peer Production Ideology
- Michel Bauwens: Is Peer Production a Real Mode of Production?
- The 'Circulation of the Common': Analytical concept proposed by Nick Dyer-Witheford in a landmark essay of the same title.. It refers to the social reproduction mechanism of Peer Production, in a process analogous with the Circulation of Capital described by Marx. [12]
- P2P Is Not a Mode of ProductionToni Prug. Journal of Peer Production, Issue 1, 2012. [13]
- How the Iron Law of Oligarchy Extends to Peer Production
See also:
- Ten Peer Production Patterns. Stefan Meretz. Comment by Michel Bauwens: A word of caution. The text by Stefan Meretz is useful to understand the post-capitalist patterns that are inherent in peer production, however, it also abstracts from its embeddedness in present society and the way these aspects are instrumentalized by the present society and economic system, and create hybrid mechanisms of mutual adaptation. It also skirts around the central question of the self-reproduction of the means of production (however, see pattern 10 on the Germ Theory of change.
- 3D Printing Community and Emerging Practices of Peer Production. By Jarkko Moilanen and Tere Vadén. First Monday, Volume 18, Number 8 - 5 August 2013 [14]
Key Books
Key Reports
From the Industrial Cooperation Project:
- Peer Production and Industrial Cooperation in Biotechnology, Genomics and Proteomics
- Peer Production and Industrial Cooperation in Alternative Energy
- Peer Production and Industrial Cooperation in Educational Materials
- Peer Production and Industrial Cooperation in Telecommunications
Key Video
Pages in category "Peerproduction"
The following 200 pages are in this category, out of 666 total.
(previous page) (next page)F
- FLOSS as Commons
- FLOSS as the Collectivism of the ICT Sector
- For Benefit
- Fora do Eixo
- Forking
- Forms and Modes of the Free Software Society
- FOSS Governance Fundamentals
- Four Future P2P Scenarios
- Fourteen Design Principles for DIY Production
- Fred Turner on Burning Man as the Cultural Infrastructure for Commons-Based Peer Production
- Free and Open Source Licenses in Community Life
- Free Hardware Design
- Free Innovation
- Free Labor
- Free Labour
- Free Open Knowledge of Production Model
- Free Software and Marxism
- Free Software and the Death of Copyright
- Free Software is not the Antonym of Commercial Software
- Free Software, the Internet, and Global Communities of Resistance
- Free, Libre Technologies, Arts and the Commons
- Friday-isation of Sunday vs the Sunday-isation of Friday
- From Exchange to Contributions
- From Peer Production To Compeerism
- From Producer Innovation to User and Open Collaborative Innovation
- From the Theory of Peer Production to the Production of Peer Production Theory
G
- Gappistas
- Gender Discrimination in Open Source Software
- George Dafermos on the Peer Governance of Open Source Projects
- Germ Form
- Gift and the New Software
- Gift Economy Software
- GitHub
- Gnu Manifesto, Peer Production and the Future of Humanity
- Good Faith Collaboration as the Culture of Wikipedia
- Governance of Peer Production is Meritocratic, not Egalitarian
- GPL User Freedom vs. Apache License Developer Freedom
- Grammar of Peer Production
- Gregers Petersen on the Anthropology of Open Source and the Market
H
- Hackerspaces and DIYbio in Asia
- Hacking Capitalism
- Hacklabs and Hackerspaces
- Hamburg’s Current Situation With Regards To Digital Fabrication and Commons-Based Peer Production
- Handbook of Peer Production
- Handbook of Research on Open Source Software
- HapMap
- Haunting Author in the Distribution of Ownership and Authority
- High-Tech Self-Production
- History and Evolution of the Commons
- Holonic Resource Planner for Open Value Networks Using the Blockchain
- Holoptism
- Homebrew Industrial Revolution
- Hope Labor and the Role of Employment Prospects in Online Social Production
- Horizontal Legibility
- How a Stigmergy of Actions Replaces Representation of Persons
- How Cooperation Triumphs over Self-Interest
- How Does the Collaboration Between the FLOSS Community and Corporations Happen
- How Firms Relate to Open Source Communities
- How Hardwareʼs Long Tail is Supporting New Engineering and Design Communities
- How Low Participation Costs Make Peer Production Inevitable
- How Open Source Hardware differs from Open Source Software
- How Open Source Has Changed the Software Industry
- How Personal Fabrication Will Change Manufacturing and the Economy
- How Students as Producer Are Hacking the University
- How the Iron Law of Oligarchy Extends to Peer Production
- How the Student as Producer is Hacking the University
- How to Contribute to Open Source Projects
- How to Reap the Benefits of the Digital Revolution, Modularity and the Commons
- How User Participation Transforms Cultural Production
- Hybrid Open Source Software Business Model
- Hybridity Between Peer Production and Firms
I
- IBM and Linux
- Idle Sourcing
- Il Manifesto Interview of Michel Bauwens
- Il potere della rete
- In Peer Production, the Interests of Capitalists and Entrepreneurs Are No Longer Aligned
- Incentivised Distributed Autonomous Commons Production
- Incidental Productivity
- Including Care and Community-Based Contributions in Peer Production
- Incorporation of the Linux Free Software Commons Into Red Hat's Capital Accumulation
- Inequalities in Open Source Software Development
- Innovation Decentralization
- Innovative, Open and Economically Sustainable Models of Creative Production
- Institutional Design of Open Source Programming
- Intellectual Origins of Value Co-Production
- Interfacing Open Peer Production Organizations with Classical Institutions
- Internet of Production Alliance
- Internet Security and the Limits of Open Source and Peer Production
- Internet Was Created Through Peer Production
- Internet – History
- Interview with Matt Asay of 10gen on Open Source Sustainability
- Interview with Michel Bauwens at the University of Oslo
- Introduction to Commons-Based Peer Production
- Introduction to Participatory and Contributions-Based Peer Production
- Introduction to the P2P Foundation Wiki Material about Relational Topics
- Introduction to the Tools and Processes of the Participatory Economy
- Is Free Digital Creative Labor Really Exploitation
- Is Peer Production a Real Mode of Production
- Is Peer Production Beyond Capitalism
J
- Jakob Rigi on Building on What We Have Achieved So Far
- Jim Zemlin on the Importance of Foundations for Collaborative Technological Development and Economics
- Job Design in FOSS
- Joe Justice on Team Wikispeed's Xtreme Manufacturing Methodology
- Joseph Reagle on How Wikipedia Works
- Joseph Reagle on the Collaborative Culture of Wikipedia
- Joss Winn
- Journal of Free Software and Free Knowledge
- Journal of Peer Production
- Journey into the Consumerization of Hacking Practices and Culture
K
L
- La Banqueta se Respeta/es
- La Casa de las Ideas
- LaFábrika-detodalavida/es
- Limits of Peer Production
- Linus Torvalds on Open Peer to Peer Design
- Linus Torvalds on the Adoption of the Linux Operating System
- Linux and the Management of Decentralized Networks
- Linux Foundation Explains How Linux Is Built
- Long Tail Mode of Production
M
- Makers as a New Work Condition Between Self-employment and Community Peer-Production
- Makerspaces and Institutions
- Making Commons for Peer Production
- Making Worlds, Building the Commons in NYC
- Mapa Subjetivo de Valladares/es
- Marco Berlinguer on How to Assess Value in Peer Production
- Marxism and Free Software
- Marxist Framework for Peer Production's Relation to Capitalism
- Mathieu O’Neil
- Maurizio Teli
- Measuring Value in the Commons-Based Ecosystem
- Methods and Tools for Community-Based Product Development
- Michel Bauwens Introducing Peer Production for the World Commons Week of the IASC
- Michel Bauwens on Commons Based Peer Production on the Blockchain
- Michel Bauwens on Open Business Models
- Michel Bauwens on P2P Production and the Coming of the Commons
- Michel Bauwens on Peer to Peer, the Open Source Economy, the Commons and Web 3.0
- Michel Bauwens on the Importance of Peer Money
- Michel Bauwens on the Relation between Peer Production and Corporations
- Mode of Production of Intellectual Commons
- Models of Software Development
- Modular Design
- Modularity
- Modularity and the Commons
- Modularity in Open Source
- Monetary Materialities of Free Peer-Produced Knowledge in Wikipedia and Its Tensions with Paid Labour
- Motivation in FOSS Software Developers
- Motivation to Join Peer Production Communities
- Motivations for Participating in Open Source Projects
- Movement for Socially Useful Production
- Mutual Coordination of Production
N
O
- Object-Oriented vs. Community-Oriented Contribution Activities
- Occupy Wall Street API
- Oekonux
- On the Difference Between Life Work and Job Work
- On the Historical and Future Connection between Peer Production and an Ethical Economy
- On the Socio-Political Potentialities of Experimental Productive Alternatives
- Online Creation Communities
- Open Airplane Development
- Open Allocation
- Open App
- Open Business Readiness Rating
- Open Coral
- Open Food Network as a Case Study of Commons Based Peer Production
- Open Hiring
- Open Materials
- Open Methods and Tools for Community-Based Product Development
- Open Network Innovation
- Open O-Meter for Open Source Hardware
- Open Platforms
- Open Platforms for Sustainable Production and Living
- Open Source - Market Aspects
- Open Source 3D Printing as a Means of Learning in Two High Schools in Greece
- Open Source and Economic Development
- Open Source as Social Process
- Open Source Business Models
- Open Source Commercialization
- Open Source Commoditization
- Open Source Competitive Strategies
- Open Source Developers and the Ethic of Capitalism
- Open Source Exploitation
- Open Source Licensing Strategies
- Open Source Methodologies
- Open Source Micro-Tasking Platform
- Open Source Project-Launch Blueprinting
- Open Source Software
- Open Source Software - Business Aspects
- Open Source Software and the Private-Collective Innovation Model
- Open Source Software Service Model
- Open Source Sustainability